The Thrill of It (No Regrets Book 2) Page 4

  “I don’t know. But I sorta like him. Even though it’s complicated, since he has bad taste in movies.”

  “That’s an awesome kind of complicated.”

  I deliver a punishing blow to the green ball, sending it careening down the hall and bouncing off the white concrete cinder block walls with several loud twangs. “Oh man! Someone is going to hear us,” I say. “But I don’t care, because I am a free bird!”

  Kristen darts in front of me, her agile field skills in play, and she slams her stick against the ball on its return path. Then she smacks the top of the ball, skipping it up in the air and catching it in her hand.

  “What are you free from?” Her eyes are brimming with curiosity. Nothing gets past this girl.

  I suppose I should feel stupid for letting “free bird” slip out, but I don’t. It felt strangely good to unspool some of my wound-up secrets with Joanne the other night, and I’ve been wanting to do the same with Kristen. To take ownership of my actions, to be honest, to let go of the past, no matter how risky that may be. Because this is the real risk—will she end our friendship when she knows? I can feel my heart beating faster, my nerves skating back and forth under the surface of my skin. This must be what it feels like to open yourself up, to let someone see who you really are.

  Especially if that person might not like what she sees.

  “Sometimes I go to group therapy,” I blurt out.

  She tilts her head to the side, furrowing her brows. “Does. Not. Compute,” she says like a robot.

  I laugh, loving her ability to be totally direct and silly too.

  “This group. It’s like a support group,” I say, and I’m still kind of embarrassed to say it.

  “Like AA? Is that why you don’t drink?”

  “Sort of, but not for alcohol addiction. For something else.” I swallow hard. “I’m in a sex and love addicts recovery group.” I don’t tell her that’s how I know Trey, or that he also attends, because that’s not my secret to tell. Instead, I start to unravel one little lie. “Because I’ve made some pretty dumbass choices about boys and men.”

  “But you’ve never even given a blow job,” she says, as if she’s found the loophole that will prove I’m wrong.

  But I push through and focus on the facts. “I know. And I’ve never had sex either. Which I know makes it seem ridiculous that I’d be in this group. But therein lies the rub. I took money for sex. Well, not sex. But weird little fetishes. I was sort of an escort.”

  Kristen drops the field hockey stick on the floor. “You were an escort?” she repeats. “Like an escort escort?”

  I nod, bracing myself for the goodbye. For the sneer. For the telltale signs that she thinks I’m disgusting. “Yes. A high-end call girl.”

  “But you never had sex with them?”

  “No. Never. Not even close.”

  She exhales loud and long, as if that will somehow help her make sense of this news. Then she holds out her hands. “I don’t get it. You were a call girl during the time we were friends in high school?”

  “I started the day I turned eighteen. So, yes. When I was a senior in high school and all through freshman year of college.”

  She smacks her palm against her forehead. “Am I stupid? How did I not notice?”

  “You’re not stupid. I’m just really accustomed to covering things up. It became a way of life for me.”

  “I can’t believe you didn’t tell me,” she says, still in a monotone voice, her eyes as wide as the moon.

  “I’m sorry,” I say, as if I’m being chided. Maybe I am. I can’t just drop this bomb on her and expect her not to jump or flinch. But at some point, I’ve learned, you have to stop running from your past. You have to stop letting it define you. “It wasn’t something I told anyone though, Kristen. It was something I did secretly. It was something, to be honest, that I was kind of addicted to.” Each word tastes strange on my tongue, but not dirty or bitter. It just tastes like a new food I’ve never tried.

  Then, as if Kristen has snapped out of her shock, she nods quickly several times. “I get it. I understand. I’m just kind of reconfiguring my hard drive now,” she says, tapping her skull. “And finding room for this new data point about you.”

  “Do you think I’m gross?” I ask, worrying away at the cuticle on my thumb.

  She shakes her head vigorously. “No.”

  “Are you sure?”

  “Positive.”

  “Why not?

  “Because you’re not. You’re you. Yeah, I really wish you’d told me sooner,” she says in that direct and honest way Kristen has. “But I also understand that it’s not something you wanted to share. And if you do want to share, I’ll listen.”

  We sit down on the linoleum floor, and I tell her more. I tell her about Morris, about Cam, about Miranda, about the book she’s making me write. I don’t tell her everything. I don’t offer up every sordid detail. Being truthful doesn’t mean you have no boundaries, and sharing a secret doesn’t mean you have to overshare. But I tell her enough, and her eyes go wider with every detail. It’s like stripping bare in front of someone, and now I want to know if everything has changed. Worry lodges deep in my belly, and my throat catches as I ask the inevitable. “Do you still want to be friends with me?”

  She rolls her eyes. “Don’t be silly. Of course. And I might want you to tell me tawdry tales from time to time so I have fodder for a screenplay someday. Could you do that?” she asks with a wink.

  I laugh once. “I’d much rather give you my stories than Miranda.”

  She smiles sympathetically. “That really does suck that you’ve had to do that.”

  “It’s pretty much been the worst homework assignment ever.”

  Kristen leans forward and pats my knee. “Hey. I know that was hard to tell me. All of that. But I also think it’s kind of cool that you trusted me enough to tell me. And now I want to ask you something, and I want you to be honest, okay?”

  I brace myself, my fear instinctually zooming back. I try to remind myself it’s okay to let people in. “Okay. Hit me.”

  “You are in love with Trey, aren’t you?”

  My breath stops. I don’t even know what love is, I want to say. Instead, I borrow a phrase from her playbook. Because it’s the truth she asked for. “It’s complicated.”

  “Or maybe it’s not. Why haven’t you seen him much in the last few days? Just busy? Or is he suffering from some tattoo-induced stupor?”

  “What do you mean?”

  “Jordan said Trey got a new tattoo today. I figured that’s why you guys weren’t together. That he was busy getting inked.”

  My stomach contorts with fear and worry. With Trey, a tattoo is never just a tattoo. It’s a symbol, it’s a message, it’s the way he expresses the things he won’t say.

  A tattoo is a cry for help.

  I need to find him. Even if he won’t call me back.

  9

  Trey

  I have my armor on. My earbuds are in and Over The Edge blasts in my head, the music a shield. I make it through the lobby, feeling like a character in a video game darting and dodging cars and trucks to cross a crowded street.

  I press the button for the elevator, and it’s empty when it arrives. I step inside, then seconds later, I hear a voice. A sexy, sultry voice.

  It’s like I’m being tested, but then that’s the point. I want the test. I’m here to prove to myself that I can do this. I can make it across the alligator-strewn waters of my parents’ apartment building.

  A gorgeous blonde with impossibly long legs and a red dress that looks as if it’s been painted on waggles her fingers at me. “Hold the elevator.”

  I swallow, my throat dry. I push the open button.

  She walks inside. “Hello there.” The words are a purr from her cherry lips.

  I grab the brass bar behind me, holding on for dear life as the elevator shoots up.

  Her stop is before mine, and she casts a quick glance at me before she
leaves. I heave a sigh as the doors close.

  I passed the first test. I picture some army dude, a colonel maybe, in a room with one-way glass, barking out orders. “Cue the cougar in the elevator. Next, roll out the MILF.”

  But seconds later, I’m at my parents’ floor. This is the real test. The assault rifles, the grenades—the army commander is preparing to launch them all at me as I head to Antarctica.

  I take out the earbuds and turn off the music. I know this hallway like the back of my hand. I could find my way in and out of this building blindfolded. This is where I grew up, became fucked up, and then was told to shut up.

  I stop at the door, taking a beat. Gritting my teeth, drawing a breath, steeling myself.

  I knock.

  My mother answers, and even though it’s late, she’s up because she rarely sleeps. She’s still dressed too. She’s wearing jeans and a button-down blouse. Her hair is in a neat ponytail. She holds a medical journal in her hand.

  “Trey, is everything okay? What are you doing here at midnight? Come in.” She gestures to the apartment, every surface perfectly and pristinely cleaned.

  I shake my head. I don’t want to go in. I don’t even want to be here. This place has a vacuum seal on feelings. I’d enter and they’d duct-tape my mouth and tell me not to say a word.

  “That’s okay. I don’t need to come in.”

  “Did you want to talk more about school? Your studies?” she asks, because these are the only acceptable topics.

  “No, I don’t want to talk about school. I wanted to show you something,” I say, and this is when I see if I can do what Michelle has been urging me to do all along. To say it. Because if I can say something to my mom, I can say it to Harley. I’m at the edge of a cliff, I’m jumping off without a parachute, and I’m hoping for a soft landing, even though I know I could crash and break every bone in my body.

  I turn to the side, pull up my shirt, and show her my new ink. The bandage has been removed.

  “These are three trees. And they’re for Will, Jake, and Drew,” I say, and she stumbles when I breathe their names aloud for the first time in years. Like she’s been punched in the gut and is winded. “And you might not ever say their names or acknowledge they existed, but I have and I will. Because I don’t want to forget them. I want to remember.”

  And that’s all. I don’t wait for a response. I don’t need a response. And I don’t warrant a response, because even after I turn around and wait endless minutes for the elevator to arrive, she doesn’t call after me, she doesn’t try to tell me she remembers too. She sticks to her guns, to her orders from when I was fifteen. Don’t talk about it.

  The doors open, and I’m inside now. I’d like to say I feel like a new man, like my life is unfurling before me. But that would be bullshit. Instead, my heart is frantic, and my skin is crawling, and I want to go jump into the ocean and swim out into the night, the stars my only companions. But there’s no ocean nearby, there’s only this claustrophobic, sticky, sweaty, smelly, muggy city that I want to escape from, that I’ve lived in my whole life, that’s made everything I’ve done possible.

  But I am also buzzing with adrenaline, because I can’t fucking believe I did that. And if I can do that, I can do something that’s more important. I can tear down the fucking walls I have built with this girl I am crazy for.

  I’m ready to find her. Ready to tell her. Ready to let her know everything. Damn the consequences. Screw the costs. Telling her everything is like inking my body. I have to go into it with no regrets.

  When the elevator opens into the lobby, my heart stops, because she is walking toward me. She knows where my parents live, of course, because she knows all sorts of stuff about me. Like where to find me.

  I don’t freeze. I don’t run to her like in the movies. I just keep moving, one foot in front of the other, and this is the real walking of the plank. This is the true blind dive. I have no clue why she’s here. All I know is she’s not dressed for work. She’s dressed for me. She’s wearing her skinny hipster jeans, all tight and dark, and a T-shirt with a cat smoking a pipe and the words No Smoking under it. She doesn’t even have her Converse on now. She has on combat boots, and I’ve never seen a girl in anything hotter than Harley in combat boots. Her hair is loose, and she has on pink lip gloss, and I want to taste it.

  Then I give myself a mental slap for automatically going to the physical. I should focus on everything else. Like why she’s here.

  “Welcome to the lion’s den,” I say, because I don’t know what the hell to say, and humor seems as reasonable as falling at her feet and telling her how I feel for her.

  She’s not having it. “Are you okay?”

  “Yeah. Why?”

  She furrows her brows like I’m crazy. “Um, hello? You haven’t answered your phone, except once and then you hung up. And you haven’t responded to a text or anything for days.”

  “I think it was two days. You know, if you’re counting.”

  She parks her hands on her hips. “Well, I am counting. I went to your apartment to find you, but you weren’t there. So I took a guess you might be here. And now I’m here.” Her voice echoes across the rose-colored marble lobby with brass trim. The doorman in a dark-maroon uniform fixes his focus on something unseen across the street, probably doing his best to pretend he can’t hear everything we’re saying. He’s good at his job—see no evil, hear no evil.

  “Let’s get out of here,” I say, and grab her elbow, gently leading her out of the building and onto the street. We walk several feet because I need space and distance from my parents. We stop near the end of the block, and I lean against the stoop of a brownstone. She stands next to me, and we’re the only ones on the quiet street at this late hour. Somewhere in the distance, a horn honks and someone shouts. But here, the space between us is carved with silence.

  I turn to her. She looks back at me. Who will make the first move? But it’s not really a question. She came to me. She found me. She hunted me down. But even if she hadn’t done those things, I still have unfinished business to account for.

  “I’m sorry I kinda disappeared the last couple of days,” I say softly.

  “Why did you disappear?”

  “I had to figure some things out. Get my shit together.”

  She inches away from me. “What did you figure out? That you don’t want to be friends with me?”

  I laugh, shaking my head. “That couldn’t be further from the truth.”

  “Jordan said you got a new tattoo. Are you going to tell me now why you keep getting them? What this obsession is? Because I think what you told me when you were drunk was true. Was it?”

  She meets my eyes without hostility, without anger, without fear. I’m struck dumb by how masterful the two of us can be at playing people, at juggling men and women and reeling off lies with vigor and abandon. But then, in quiet moments, she can strip that away and ask me for all my truths.

  I lick my lips, then part them to speak, and I feel mute again, like when she called. For the briefest moment, I have the sensation that my entire world will come down on me, that the buildings on the other side of the block will break free, topple over, and crush me. That I will die. But then I tested that hypothesis a few minutes ago outside my parents’ door, and I’m still standing.

  It’s now or never. And one thing I know for sure—never isn’t an option.

  “Yeah. It’s all true,” I admit.

  “Oh, Trey.” Her throat hitches, and her eyes are brimming with sadness. She steps closer and touches my arm, rubbing her fingertips against my skin. “I’m so sorry. Do you want to tell me about them? About Will, Jake, and Drew?”

  I stumble like I’ve been hit. But she grabs my hand, steadying me. “You remember their names?” I can’t believe it. I can’t believe she remembers.

  “Yes,” she says with a nod. She links her fingers through mine and leads me to the nearby stoop. I follow her, and the feel of her hand in mine is extraordinary. She sits dow
n, turns to me, and takes both of my hands in hers. I watch her, amazed that she’s not looking away, that she’s not going anywhere. That she wants to listen and she cares. Deeply.

  “Tell me.”

  So I begin at the beginning.

  My parents were young when they had me, just finishing their residencies. I was the only child for a long time, but when I was twelve, they were ready to expand their family, they said. They were established, with a well-respected plastic surgery practice that was worth a mint. They were raking it in and ready to have a bigger family.

  Soon my mom was pregnant with another boy. All was well, and her pregnancy was picture perfect. But at four and a half months, I heard her wake up shrieking at four in the morning, then my dad rushed into my room, told me he was taking her to the hospital and that Mrs. Fitzpatrick down the hall would come stay with me.

  I didn’t go back to sleep that night.

  I stared at the clock and waited. When morning came, Mrs. Fitzpatrick told me to get ready for school. She took me to the deli at the end of the street, bought me a bagel, and walked me to school, even though I knew the route myself, thank you very much. When the day ended, my dad was waiting for me on the steps of the school.

  He shook his head, giving me a sad smile, and then when we were far enough away from the school, he wrapped me in the kind of hug you give when you’ve lost someone and you want to hold on dearly to those you have left.

  “We had a son. He was too small to live,” my father said, choking out the words, his eyes rimmed with red.

  “I don’t understand. What happened?”

  “Her water broke too soon.”

  “So, where’s the baby?”

  “She was only twenty weeks pregnant. He couldn’t survive.”

  I was glad we were blocks away from my school. I didn’t want anyone to see me cry, but I could feel the tears prick at the back of my eyes, threatening me.

  “What did you name him?”

  My father tilted his head as if the question didn’t make sense.